is child tax credit the same as child benefit

Is Child Tax Credit the Same as Child Benefit?

Child tax credit and child benefit are forms of financial support the UK government provides to families with children. Although they share a common aim – to support families – they differ. Each has specific features, eligibility criteria, and payment methods.

By reading this article, you will learn:

  • The crucial differences between child tax credit and child benefit
  • How these two forms of financial support can help families
  • The main features of each scheme
  • The benefits of understanding these two forms of support
  • How to apply this knowledge to your circumstances

Is Child Tax Credit the Same as Child Benefit?

Child tax credit and child benefit are different forms of financial assistance, each with unique characteristics. The child tax credit is a benefit given to families with children who have a low income. It’s part of the system of tax credits, which also includes working tax credit. It’s important to note that child tax credit has been replaced by universal credit for most people.

On the other hand, child benefit is a regular payment made to parents or guardians of children under 16 or under 20 if they stay in approved education or training. It is not means-tested, which means it’s available to all qualifying families, regardless of income or wealth.

What is Child Tax Credit?

Child tax credit was a type of tax credit designed to support families with children. It was available to low-income families with children under 16 or 20 in approved education or training. However, for most people, making a new claim for child tax credit is impossible. Instead, you’ll need to apply for universal credit.

The amount of child tax credit you could receive depended on several factors, including your income and the number of children you have. The child tax credit included elements for each child, known as the child element, and additional elements for disabled children, known as the disabled child element.

Key Features of Child Benefit

Child benefit is a payment made to parents or guardians of children under 16 or under 20 if they stay in approved education or training. It’s paid every 4 weeks, and there’s no limit to how many children you can claim for.

The amount you get depends on who the allowance is for. There’s a higher amount for your eldest (or only) child and a lower amount for any additional children. However, if your individual or partner’s income exceeds a specific limit, you may have to pay a tax charge known as the ‘High Income Child Benefit Tax Charge.

Comparing Child Tax Credit and Child Benefit

The most significant difference between child tax credit and child benefit is in eligibility criteria and payment amounts. Child tax credit was means-tested, and the amount varied based on income and family size. In contrast, child benefit is not means-tested and is paid at the same rate, regardless of income, although a tax charge applies if income is over a specific limit.

Another key difference lies in their administration. Child tax credit was managed by HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC), through the tax credit office. Child benefit, on the other hand, is managed by the Child Benefit Office.

In conclusion, while both child tax credit and child benefit provide vital support to families, they are different in their design, eligibility criteria, and administration. Understanding these differences can help families navigate the range of available financial support and ensure they receive the support they are entitled to.

Pros and Cons of Child Tax Credit and Child Benefit

When examining the financial support systems available for families in the UK, it’s essential to look at both the positive and negative aspects. Here, we will explore some of the pros and cons of the child tax credit and child benefit, to better understand how they can impact families.

Advantages of Child Tax Credit and Child Benefit

The benefits of understanding and accessing child tax credit and child benefit can be numerous for eligible families. Let’s delve into some of these advantages.

1) Financial Support for Low-Income Families

  • Child tax credit provided targeted financial support to low-income families, helping to alleviate the burden of child-rearing costs. This benefited households where parents were employed but earning less than the national average income.
  • The introduction of the universal credit payment system, which has now absorbed the child tax credit, streamlined the process by combining several benefits into one monthly payment, simplifying financial planning for families.

2) Universal Support for Families with Children

  • Child benefit is available to all parents in the UK with children under 16 or 20 if in approved education or training, regardless of household income. This ensures a basic level of support for every child.
  • The ease of access to child benefit payments helps protect children from poverty by providing a consistent, reliable source of additional income for families.

3) Support for Childcare Costs

  • For working parents, access to tax credits can include additional support for childcare costs. This is valuable in enabling parents to remain at work, knowing that some childcare expenses will be met.
  • Tax-free childcare is another scheme designed to help with childcare costs, where for every £8 a parent pays into their Tax-Free Childcare account, the government will add an extra £2, up to £2,000 per child per year.

4) Additional Support for Disabled Children

  • Families with disabled children could receive the disabled child element of child tax credit, providing essential financial help for the extra care and support these children may require.
  • The child disability payment and disability living allowance for children are designed to help with the additional costs of caring for a child who has disabilities, ensuring they can access the same opportunities as others.

5) Positive Impact on Child Poverty

  • Benefits such as child tax credit and child benefit have played a crucial role in reducing child poverty rates in the UK. These payments can significantly impact children’s daily lives, affording them better nutrition, clothing, and educational resources.
  • The Scottish child payment and other targeted schemes such as the early learning payment and the baby payment in Scotland, are examples of how such benefits can be tailored to address child poverty more effectively.
Comparing Child Tax Credit and Child Benefit

Disadvantages of Child Tax Credit and Child Benefit

Despite the clear benefits, there are also some drawbacks and challenges associated with child tax credit and child benefit that must be acknowledged.

1) Complexity and Changes in the System

  • Transitioning from individual benefits like child tax to universal credit has confused many families. Adapting to new claims procedures can be a complex process requiring guidance from sources like Citizens Advice.
  • The eligibility criteria for tax credits and benefits can be complex, and understanding the impact of changes in circumstances on your entitlement can be challenging for parents without the proper support.

2) High-Income Child Benefit Tax Charge

  • For families where one parent earns above a certain threshold, the High Income Child Benefit Tax Charge claws back some of the benefit. This can create an unexpected tax liability for higher earners who don’t opt out of receiving child benefit.
  • The charge has been criticised for creating a ‘cliff-edge’ effect, where just a small increase in income can lead to a disproportionate loss in overall family benefit.

3) Delays and Backlogs in Processing Claims

  • The administrative burden on the HM Revenue and Customs and the Child Benefit Office can delay claims and payments. This can significantly impact family finances, particularly those relying on these payments to meet essential needs.
  • Errors in claims or changes in family circumstances can lead to overpayments that families may later have to repay, causing financial stress and uncertainty.

4) Potential Disincentive to Work More

  • The means-tested nature of child tax credit could act as a disincentive to work more hours or earn more income, as increased earnings could reduce the benefit received.
  • Some families may find that additional work does not significantly improve their financial situation due to reduced benefits, affecting employment decisions.

5) Impact on National Insurance Contributions

  • Some tax credits and benefits may impact a parent’s National Insurance contributions record, which can have long-term effects on entitlements like the state pension.
  • Parents need to understand how receiving certain benefits instead of a salary can affect their National Insurance record, potentially influencing their pension credit eligibility when they reach the state pension age.

Tax Credits for Dependent Children

In the UK, families with dependent children may be eligible for tax credits designed to provide financial support and ease the burden on household income. Tax credits for dependent children were often based on net income to help low- and middle-income families. However, the transition to universal credit has seen these tax credits evolve into a different system.

For families in Northern Ireland, as in the rest of the UK, claiming tax credits follows a similar process, with a few regional variations. The family element of the tax credit, an additional amount for those responsible for at least one child, has been phased out for new claimants and absorbed into the universal credit system. Parents can use a benefits calculator to estimate the support they could receive, which is particularly helpful when dealing with a change in circumstance, such as the arrival of a subsequent child.

When a young person reaches their 16th birthday, there may be changes to the tax credits received. It’s essential to update the relevant agencies to ensure the correct entitlement. Additionally, some aspects like the childcare element, can be claimed to help with registered childcare provider costs.

Housing Benefit and Child Support

Housing benefit is a type of income support the UK government provides to help cover rent for those on low income or claiming other benefits. It can be a vital resource for families, ensuring that even if their net income falls short, their housing needs are met. This benefit is gradually being replaced by universal credit, which includes a housing element to assist with rental costs.

Child maintenance is another crucial aspect of financial support, particularly for single parents. It involves payments from the non-resident parent to the parent with whom the child lives, contributing to the child’s upbringing and expenses. While this is not a public fund managed by the government, the Child Maintenance Service can help parents set up, manage, and enforce child maintenance payments.

Childcare vouchers were available to some parents to help with childcare costs. This scheme allowed parents to sacrifice a portion of their salary before income tax and National Insurance were deducted, effectively paying for childcare out of their pre-tax income. This scheme has now closed to new entrants and has been replaced by the tax-free childcare scheme, which operates differently but with a similar aim—reducing the financial burden of childcare on working parents.

Additional Support Funds and Allowances

The household support fund is an additional source of financial assistance available to help with immediate needs. It’s designed to help those struggling due to exceptional circumstances or sudden financial difficulty. While not explicitly tied to families with children, it can be a lifeline for parents facing unexpected hardship.

Maternity allowance is a benefit paid to pregnant women who do not qualify for statutory maternity pay from their employer. It’s designed to support new mothers who are employees or self-employed, allowing them to take time off work to care for their newborn without the worry of losing their entire income.

In the context of social security, the UK offers various benefits to support families with children. These include the child element of universal credit, which provides additional financial support for each eligible child within a family. It’s essential for parents to stay informed about the available public funds and to claim any benefits they are entitled to, ensuring they can provide for their children’s needs effectively.

Case Study on Child Benefit and Tax Credits

Case Study on Child Benefit and Tax Credits

Here is a case study to help bring the topic of whether child tax credit is the same as child benefit to life in a real-world context. By examining an individual’s experience, this example aims to provide insight that many can relate to while highlighting the distinctions between these two forms of financial support.

In the UK, a single parent named Sarah navigates the complexities of financial assistance for her dependent child. After the birth of her son, she learned that while child benefit is a universal payment for all parents, child tax credit (now replaced by universal credit for new claimants) was a means-tested benefit designed to help low-income families.

Sarah initially claimed for tax credits and received payments that helped her manage childcare costs. As she was on a low income, these credits were vital to her financial stability. She chose a registered childcare provider, which allowed her to qualify for the childcare element of her tax credits. Sarah also made a joint claim with her ex-partner, ensuring that the Child Tax Credit Office considered both parents’ incomes and circumstances when calculating her entitlement.

When the tax credits system transitioned to universal credit, Sarah found that her benefit payments were rolled into a single monthly universal credit payment. She discovered that she could benefit from the tax-free childcare scheme, which reduced her ongoing childcare costs. This new system required her to reevaluate her childcare choices, ensuring they were affordable and compatible with her new financial support structure.

Despite the changes, Sarah continued to receive child benefit for her son, unaffected by her earnings or claim for tax credits. This case study illustrates the importance of understanding the different types of support available to parents in the UK and how they can adapt to changes in the social security system.

Key Takeaways and Learnings

The article has delved into the details surrounding the query, “Is child tax credit the same as child benefit?” Now, let’s summarise the article by highlighting the critical aspects of each benefit.

  • Child tax credit and child benefit are different forms of financial support, with child tax credit being means-tested and now mostly replaced by universal credit.
  • Child benefit is a universal payment available to all parents with eligible children, regardless of income, although subject to a tax charge for higher earners.
  • Tax credits, including child tax credit, were designed to support low-income families, with the amount received based on various factors such as income and family size.
  • Universal credit has absorbed the child tax credit and now provides a monthly payment that includes a child element to assist with the costs of raising children.
  • Tax-free childcare is a scheme that helps working parents with childcare costs, providing them with a government top-up on contributions to their childcare accounts.
  • It’s important for parents to understand the benefits they’re entitled to and to keep their information up to date with the relevant agencies, such as the Child Benefit Office and the Tax Credit Office.

In conclusion, understanding the differences between child tax credit and child benefit is crucial for parents and guardians in the UK. These benefits play a significant role in providing financial assistance to families, each with its own rules and eligibility criteria. Staying informed is critical as policies and systems evolve, like the shift from individual tax credits to universal credit. The case study presented offers a practical look at how these benefits can be navigated in everyday life, clarifying the complex landscape of financial support for families with children. It’s essential for eligible parties to stay abreast of changes and to make the most of the support available to them.


1) How Does Tax-Free Childcare Work in the UK?

Tax-free childcare is a scheme in the UK that supports working parents with their childcare costs. For every £8 paid into a tax-free childcare account, the government adds £2, up to £2,000 per child per year (£4,000 for disabled children). This is a significant benefit for parents, as it reduces the overall cost of childcare, making it more affordable for families to balance work and parenting responsibilities.

To be eligible for tax-free childcare, parents must be working and each earning at least the National Minimum Wage or Living Wage for 16 hours a week on average. The scheme is open to self-employed parents as well. It’s important to note that parents cannot receive tax-free childcare while claiming childcare vouchers, universal credit, or tax credits. Therefore, evaluating which option provides the best financial support for your circumstances is essential.

2) Can I Claim for Tax-Free Childcare If I’m Self-Employed?

Yes, self-employed parents are eligible to claim for tax-free childcare, provided they meet the minimum income requirement. This scheme helps self-employed individuals balance work and family life by reducing the financial burden of childcare. If you’re starting a business and do not expect to make enough profit in your first year, you can still be eligible, as the government provides a ‘start-up period’ during which the minimum income requirement does not apply.

Self-employed parents must reconfirm their circumstances every three months to ensure they qualify for tax-free childcare. This involves confirming that your income meets the minimum requirement and your child is still eligible. This system ensures that the financial support is accurately tailored to the family’s current needs.

3) What Should I Do If My Circumstances Change and I’m No Longer Eligible for Tax-Free Childcare?

If your circumstances change, such as a significant increase or decrease in income, or you no longer meet the eligibility criteria for tax-free childcare, you must inform HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) as soon as possible. Changes in your situation can affect the amount of support you’re entitled to, and it’s essential to keep your information up to date to avoid overpayments or underpayments.

If you’re no longer eligible for tax-free childcare, other forms of support may be available to you, such as universal credit or childcare vouchers if you had joined the scheme before it closed to new entrants. It’s advisable to seek guidance from a professional or a trusted organisation like Citizens Advice to explore the best options for your family.

4) Is Tax-Free Childcare Available for Every Child in the Family?

Tax-free childcare is available for every eligible child in the family. Parents can set up a tax-free childcare account for each of their children, up to the age of 11 (or 17 if the child has a disability), and receive the government top-up for each one. This ensures that larger families can receive adequate support towards the costs of childcare for all their children.

The scheme is designed to be flexible, and parents can deposit funds into their tax-free childcare account as and when it suits them, up to the maximum government top-up threshold per child. This is particularly helpful for parents with varying incomes or those who need to manage their finances carefully across multiple children’s childcare expenses.

Disclaimer: Please be aware that this site is no longer under active management. As a result, we cannot assure the accuracy or relevance of the content provided. Visitors should use their discretion and consider the potential for outdated or inaccurate information before relying on any material found here.

Disclaimer: Please be aware that this site is no longer under active management. As a result, we cannot assure the accuracy or relevance of the content provided. Visitors should use their discretion and consider the potential for outdated or inaccurate information before relying on any material found here.